Making (up?) the grade

Report CardWest Virginia higher education faculty sure are prickly when it comes to allegations of making up grades for students who happen to be the daughters of powerful public officials.  The latest allegation is that West Virginia State Treasurer John Perdue’s daughter Emily had two incomplete grades changed to A’s by a dean at Marshall University without Miss Perdue’s professor’s knowledge and approval.

In yesterday’s newspaper, Miss Perdue and her father talked to a reporter about the story.  For those of you who were saturated and satiated with coverage of the WVU-Bresch degree scandal, stop reading the newspaper for a few more days.

Interestingly, there appear to be some significant similarities and differences between this story and the Bresch story.

Significant similarities:

  • The daughter of a powerful politician;
  • A fairly quick investigation/decision by the provost (vulnerable to second-guessing as a “rush to judgment”);
  • A decision that favored the daughter; and
  • FERPA (privacy law) violations by an individual or individuals seeking to expose the “truth.”

Significant differences:

  • We are talking about grades in two classes, not a full-blown degree.
  • Miss Perdue actually can produce work that she completed.  She also claims to have met with the dean on multiple occasions recently, which should be easily verifiable.
  • Miss Perdue has a reasonably good GPA and appears to be a fairly conscientious student.
  • This professor may have an axe to grind with the dean.
  • To date, there’s no evidence whatsoever that the State Treasurer or friends of the State Treasurer did anything to influence the outcome.
  • To date, there’s no evidence of presidential involvement (beyond, I would hope, his being apprised of the results of the provost’s investigation) or connections to Miss Perdue or her father.
  • This issue appears to have been treated as the truly academic matter it is.

Predictions:

  • You’ll be learning about several things you probably should not, given federal student privacy laws, as this story unfolds.  This is a serious downside to being a politican’s daughter; you are a public figure whether or not you want to be.
  • This story will not have the “legs” that the Bresch story had because of the “axe-grinding” issue and the evidence that work actually was completed.
Tagged with:  

The West Virginia Legislature’s failure to approve a $500 bonus-like bonus payment for full-time state employees during the recently-completed special session raises several interesting issues not addressed by local media.

  • As a general rule, nothing goes on the Governor’s call unless there’s general agreement.  What happened?  During Governor Manchin’s first term, he wielded a lot of power.  Now he can’t get a feel-good $500 bonus payment for state workers approved.  Is this an example of his lame-duck status?
  • The annual increment law clearly covers higher education employees.  Why did the Governor not include funds for those employees?  Did the Governor expect students’ tuition and fees to pay for the bonuses – or that higher education employees would not receive the bonuses?
  • Did anyone question whether this was the best way to reward state workers?  If you have a limited pool of funds, should you give it to everyone equally or try to determine who is most deserving?
  • Using the money for employee benefits would be tax-free, while these bonuses probably would be taxed at a heightened rate.  Did anyone wonder whether it might be better to use these funds to offset health insurance premium payments or to cover retirement program debts?
Tagged with:  

I’m not one of those Americans who wants to change the name of French fries to Freedom fries any time a foreigner offers an opinion of or says something critical of the United States.  That is why I am a fan of the Economist.

This week the Economist includes an opinion piece about President Barack Obama.  My favorite quotation:  ”He has been curiously ill-served by a press short of useful criticism, with liberal America prepared only to debate what sort of water he walks on best, while conservative radio hosts argue over when exactly he became a communist.”  I can come up with no sentence that better captures the left-right media divide – and the utter uselessness of their chatter – better.

Meanwhile, notes the Economist, President Obama is losing the support of independent voters, who are concerned about federal spending, and needs to show leadership on important issues like health care and environmental reform.  ”Back in the honeymoon days,” says the Economist, “Mr. Obama was constantly compared to Roosevelt.  No longer.”

I recently had an opportunity to read FDR’s fireside chats.  FDR would talk directly to the American people about important issues in plain, easy to understand, but not condescending, language.  I think President Obama needs to do more of this.  It’s harder now, with so many media competing for our limited attentions, but he needs to make a conscientious effort to reach us.

In closing, some interesting words from FDR to ponder:

  • On stimulus spending: “It is going to cost something to get out of this recession this way but the profit of getting out of it will pay for the cost several times over. Lost working time is lost money. Every day that a workman is unemployed, or a machine is unused, or a business organization is marking time, it is a loss to the Nation.”  14 April 1938.
  • On health care: “Whether we come to this form of insurance soon or later on, I am confident that we can devise a system which will enhance and not hinder the remarkable progress which has been made and is being made in practice of the professions of medicine and surgery in the United States.”  14 November 1936.
  • On the environment: “If, for example, in some local area the water table continues to drop and the topsoil to blow away, the land values will disappear with the water and the soil. People on the farms will drift into the nearby cities; the cities will have no farm trade and the workers in the city factories and stores will have no jobs. Property values in the cities will decline. If, on the other hand, the farms within that area remain as farms with better water supply and no erosion, the farm population will stay on the land and prosper and the nearby cities will prosper too. Property values will increase instead of disappearing.”  6 September 1936.
Tagged with:  

The Charleston Daily Mail ran an odd editorial on Tuesday urging people to donate to the major political parties.  ”It is too bad that West Virginians care so little about democracy and state politics,” said the editorial.  ”It was 233 years ago that a group of men in Philadelphia pledged their lives, their fortunes and their sacred honor for the independence of this great nation.  Is it too much for voters in West Virginia to give a buck or two to the political party of their choice?”

I think the Daily Mail is confusing democracy with political partisanship.  If I remember correctly, there were no political parties when that august group of gentlemen pledged their lives, their fortunes and their sacred honor in Phily.  If these men had known the levels to which political party squabbling could degenerate, I daresay they might have decided to stick with the Brits.

Tagged with:  

Comebacks

Yesterday there was news about two people who have been at the forefront of education news over the last few years.

It is good to see people who have struggled doing so well.

Tagged with:  
Page 3 of 512345
CONTACT

© 2010 DCT Advisors LLC
Post Office Box 224
3288 Winfield Road
Winfield, West Virginia 25213
Phone: 304.541.0332
Fax: 866.783.0511
Email: dct@dctadvisors.com

text

LEGAL DISCLAIMER

THIS IS NOT A LEGAL ADVERTISEMENT. DCT Advisors performs exclusively non-legal work. The materials on this website have been prepared for informational purposes and are not legal advice, nor do they create a lawyer-client relationship.